Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

Chili cook-off score sheet and ballot, with a guide to judging

Start a chili cook-off scorecard See a sample

A score sheet to print for judges and a People's Choice ballot for guests. Below them: what judges look for, blind cups, ties, entry rules and wing criteria.

Score sheet for judges

Score each pot from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) on the five criteria, then add the row into the Total column. The best possible total is 25.

Chili cook-off score sheet: one row per numbered entry, 1 to 5 per criterion
EntryAromaColorConsistencyTasteAftertasteTotal (25)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

Judge name:  

Tie: the higher Taste score wins. If that is level too, fresh judges re-taste the tied cups. ICS also breaks ties with fresh judges.

People's Choice ballot for guests

Guests write the number of the cup they liked best. Cut along the dashed lines, hand one slip to each guest and count the numbers at the end.

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

People's Choice

My favorite chili is entry number  

Or skip the paper: score on phones. Guests rate each numbered pot and the ranking appears when you close voting.

What judges look for

These five are a common set for chili sheets:

Aroma
The first impression when the lid comes off. Does it smell like chili, with the spices and meat in balance?
Color
Does it look appetizing? A red chili should look rich and even. A white or green chili is judged on its own terms.
Consistency
Meat tender without turning to mush, sauce neither watery nor paste-thick, and a sensible ratio of sauce to meat.
Taste
What most judges weigh highest. Seasoning, depth, and heat that is noticeable without drowning everything else.
Aftertaste
What stays a few seconds after swallowing. A warm finish is good; bitterness or a burn that wipes out the next taste is not.

The International Chili Society gives its judges similar guidance in its official rules (PDF): tender meat, sauce of the right thickness with real chili flavor, heat that is neither bland nor overpowering, and in the end, the bowl the judge personally likes best.

Rate every pot, or rank the top three

Two ways to turn tastings into a winner:

  • Rate each entry on a scale (1 to 5 or 1 to 10), then rank by the average. Every pot gets a score, so you also see how close second and third were. Some sheets score each criterion separately and add them up, which takes longer and often gives the same winner.
  • Rank the top three. ICS-sanctioned cook-offs work this way: each judge names a first, second and third place, the scorekeeper gives 3, 2 and 1 points, and the highest total wins. It is quick for experienced judges with many cups on the table.

For a casual cook-off where every guest votes, rating is easier. Guests do not have to keep ten pots in their head, and someone who only tried four can still vote on those four.

Numbered cups and no garnish

  1. Ask one person who is not cooking to collect the pots or cups and number them in random order. Write the key (number to cook) on a piece of paper and keep it out of sight.
  2. Use identical cups, bowls or slow cookers if you can. A distinctive pot gives the cook away.
  3. Leave garnishes off. Cheese, sour cream or a cilantro sprig on one entry makes it recognizable, and ICS rules ban garnishes for the same reason. Put toppings out after voting.
  4. Keep cooks away from the tasting table while judging is on, and ask judges not to talk, pull faces or gesture while tasting (ICS rules ask the same of their judges). One "wow" changes how the next person tastes.

At the tasting table

  • A clean spoon for every taste. Small sample cups and a box of plastic spoons work well.
  • Palate cleansers between tastes. ICS suggests bite-size pieces of flour tortilla, sour cream and bottled water. Plain crackers or bread work too.
  • Keep samples small. Two tablespoons per pot is plenty, and with eight pots that is already about a cup.
  • If one entry is much hotter than the rest, let people taste it last so it does not numb them for the others.
  • Re-tasting is fine. ICS judges may re-taste a cup until they have chosen their top three.

How many judges

ICS asks for at least one judge for every two bowls, or at least five judges per judging table, so 12 pots means about 6 judges. At a party you can let every guest vote instead. More voters make one person's odd taste matter less.

Breaking a tie

ICS breaks a tie with fresh judges who did not taste that round: three of them for a two-way tie, five for a three-way tie, always an odd number. They taste only the tied entries and their votes decide the place. At home, the same idea works with whoever has the cleanest palate left: two or three people taste the tied pots side by side and pick one.

On the phone vote, an entry with more ratings ranks above one with the same average; equal on both, they share the place. Options for small contests:

  • Re-taste: two or three people with fresh palates taste only the tied entries, side by side, and pick one. Keep the numbers on while they do.
  • One row decides: on a paper sheet, compare the tied entries on the row that matters most for the contest, such as taste for chili, flavor at a bake-off or creativity at a costume party.
  • Share it: two winners split the prize, which suits a family table better than a re-taste.

Decide the rule before you start, write it on the entry sheet and say it out loud. A tie-break invented after the scores are in always looks like it favors someone.

Chili cook-off rules for the cooks

These entry rules come from three town rule sheets, the Trussville Parks and Rec rules (2021), the Hillsville, VA Chili Shootout FAQ and the Urbanna chili contest page, each with the reason it is there.

Chili cook-off entry rules with the reason for each
RuleReason
Made by the entrant, brought fully cookedTrussville requires it. Cooking raw meat on site needs a kitchen and takes time, and a hall or office rarely has either.
Bring your own heatTrussville asks for a slow cooker or a chafing dish with fuel. A pot that cools on the table is a food-safety problem and tastes worse than the pot beside it.
Serve at 140°F or aboveUrbanna asks for chili to arrive hot (140°F or above) or chilled to 40°F or below, then heated to serving temperature on-site. Put 140°F on the sheet and keep a probe thermometer at the check-in table. Check your local health department's rules too.
Ingredient card with every potTrussville collects a list from each entrant. Guests with a bean, nut or dairy allergy can check it without asking the cook.
Register ahead, with a capTrussville closes sign-up two days before the event and may limit entries. A cap keeps the tasting table to a number guests can finish; a guest who tries 12 pots has eaten a bowl of chili.
Cooks clean their own spotTrussville makes every contestant responsible for set-up and clean-up, which keeps the host out of the dish pile.
Entry fee (optional)Hillsville charges $25 per team of up to four people. A fee can cover cups and prizes at a public event; a family or office party can skip it.

Define chili before anything else, because it decides who can enter. Trussville counts any combination of meats with spices, tomatoes, onions, peppers, beans and a liquid, and accepts vegetarian entries; Hillsville's open class wants meat cooked with chili peppers and spices. Trussville also gives vegetarian, unusual and hottest chili their own prizes, so a white chili does not have to beat a Texas red.

The street festivals ask for a lot: about two gallons per entrant at Trussville, four gallons plus a quart for the judges at Hillsville, and five at Urbanna. For a party, work it out from your guest count. A gallon is 128 ounces, so a 2-ounce taste gives 64 samples per gallon. Thirty guests tasting 5 pots is 150 samples, 30 per pot, which is 2 quarts per pot with no spare; fifty guests tasting 8 pots is just under a gallon each. Add a margin for seconds. Buy the cups and spoons yourself (one of each per guest per pot, plus ten percent), since a cook's own cups give the pot away.

Hillsville runs a judged cup (one quart to sequestered judges) and a People's Choice decided by visitors as two separate prizes. Name both on your sheet, because judges and a crowd often pick different pots. Trussville ends its rules with "No arguing over results, appeals, or protests will be allowed." A rule sheet to copy:

  1. Chili is meat or vegetarian, cooked with chili peppers, spices and a liquid. Beans are allowed.
  2. Cook it yourself and bring it fully cooked in a slow cooker, at 140°F or above.
  3. Bring [quart or gallon figure from your guest count] and an ingredient card.
  4. The organizer numbers the pots. Cooks do not serve their own pot.
  5. One vote per guest. Each pot is rated 1 to 5 on the scorecard link.
  6. Prizes: People's Choice, plus [your extra categories].
  7. Ties: [your tie-break from the section above]. The result is final.
  8. Cooks clean up their own spot.

Wing cook-off judging criteria

Wings go soft within minutes and one hot wing can flatten every wing after it, so a wing sheet scores sauce, meat, skin and heat apart, 100 points in all.

Wing cook-off scoring criteria with maximum points
CriterionMaxLow scoresHigh scores
Sauce and flavor30Sauce tastes of one thing only (heat or vinegar), tastes of raw spice, or slides off the wing.The sauce or rub clings, has layers beyond heat, and you can still taste the chicken.
Meat20Dry, stringy, or pink at the bone. Rubbery meat that was cooked straight from cold.Juicy all the way through, pulls cleanly off the bone, seasoned beneath the sauce.
Skin and crispness20Soft and flabby, or burnt. Breading that falls off in the sauce. A greasy film on the fingers.Skin rendered and crisp (or a crust that stays on), even after being tossed in sauce.
Heat balance15Heat that numbs everything after the first wing, or no heat at all on a wing billed as hot.Heat that matches what the cook promised and leaves room for the next bite.
Overall15You would not go back for a second.You would take two more off the tray.

The Wing Standard scores six categories from 0 to 5, including sauce-to-wing ratio and heat accuracy. Judge heat against the label on the card: a wing marked mild that makes eyes water loses points, and so does an "atomic" wing that tastes like ketchup. A dry rub has no sauce, so score its rub in the sauce row. On a tie, the higher sauce score wins.

Wing contests split prizes by style. The Wings Over the Bay cook-off in Cutler Bay, Florida gives trophies in Buffalo, Special Grill and Parmesan Garlic, and the Florida Gators' Swamp Wing Cook-Off scored overall, traditional and dry rub. With six or more entries, a sauced class and a dry rub class work at home. Both the Union, Missouri Wingfest (10 wings per team, 5 judges) and the Berlin Boat Club contest (6 wings to the judges) give each judge one wing per entry. With one piece per taster per entry, 30 tasters means about 30 pieces from each cook, roughly 3 to 4 pounds of whole wings (an estimate).

  • Check the temperature. The Union rules require every wing to reach an internal 165°F, and USDA's safe minimum for poultry is the same. Ask each cook to check a wing with a thermometer before plating.
  • Keep hot wings hot. A USDA fact sheet says hot food stays at 140°F or above, in a preheated oven, chafing dish, warming tray or slow cooker, and out no longer than 2 hours (1 hour above 90°F).
  • Sauce late. Sauce softens skin under foil, so cooks toss just before their tray goes out or serve it on the side.
  • A card by each number with the heat the cook is aiming for, the cooking method, and any dairy, honey, soy or nuts. It lists ingredients only, so it does not give the cook away.
  • Serve mild to hot on identical plain plates, with celery, plain bread, water and a creamy dip between wings, and wet wipes at each seat.

Start a wing cook-off scorecard

Cup numbers and the phone ballot

The scorecard uses the rating method: each guest gives every pot one score from 1 to 5, and the ranking is the average. Ask them to keep aroma, color, consistency, taste and aftertaste in mind. One scorecard holds up to 20 entries.

Number the cups in the same order you typed the entries, so Entry 3 on the phone is cup 3 on the table. The host page has a printable table card with a QR code for the vote link. For a lunch at work, see the office chili cook-off planner. Serving salsa and chips next to the pots? The salsa contest score sheet has its own heat row.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Start a chili cook-off scorecard. The title is filled in; add your entries and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?