Contest score sheets to print, or vote on phones
Each sheet has a tally sheet for adding up the judges. Retype the title and criteria on the page before you print.
Free printable score sheets and ballots
- Trunk-or-treat score sheetOne page per decorated car, 100 points. Tally for 15 cars
- Cookie contest score sheetNumbered plates, texture judged by cookie type. Tally for 12 plates
- Salsa contest judging sheet1 to 5 per criterion, heat scored for fit. Tally for 8 bowls
- Bake-off score sheetOne sheet for bread, bars and cakes on one table. Tally for 10 bakes
- Pie contest score sheet100 points with a crust score of its own. Tally for 8 pies
Ballots for a crowd vote are on the chili cook-off page (a People's Choice slip) and the costume contest page (one pick per award). Every other contest type has a guide with its own sheet further down, under judging guides.
Skip the paper: guests vote on their phones and it tallies for you
Guests rate numbered entries on their own phones. Everyone sees the ranking when you close voting.
- Free
- No app or account for guests
- Takes about a minute to set up
- See a sample
Start from an example
Each one fills in a title and example entries. Change both to your own.
- Pie contest
- Cookie bake-off
- Cake contest
- Bake-off
- Blind taste test
- Family holiday contest
- Salsa contest
- Pumpkin carving contest
- Costume contest
- Ugly sweater contest
- Office decorating contest
- Gingerbread house contest
- Friendsgiving dish contest
- Soup cook-off
- Wing cook-off
- Trunk-or-treat contest
- Big game ad ratings
- Holiday lights contest
- Chili cook-off
How it works
- Create the scorecard. You get a host page with a link for guests and a private host link.
- Print the table card (it has a QR code for the guest link) or send the link to the group chat.
- Guests rate the numbered entries from 1 to 5, or pick one entry per award if you chose awards. Ballots are anonymous.
- Close voting on the host page. The ranking with the entry names appears for anyone with the results link.
See a sample contest to view the guest ballot and the results page.
What the ranking looks like
Example with made-up numbers, not a real contest.
- #1 Dad's pumpkin (Entry 3)4.6 / 5, 9 ratings
- #2 Aunt Lisa's pecan (Entry 1)4.2 / 5, 9 ratings
- #3 Sam's apple (Entry 2)3.8 / 5, 8 ratings
Worked example: a 6-entry chili contest with 12 voters
Guests rate each cup from 1 to 5 and may skip entries they did not try. The scorecard averages the ratings per entry, rounds to two decimals and sorts by that average.
| Entry | Sum | Ratings | Average | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Entry 3 | 46 | 11 | 4.18 | #1 |
| Entry 1 | 50 | 12 | 4.17 | #2 |
| Entry 2 | 46 | 12 | 3.83 | #3 |
| Entry 4 | 42 | 12 | 3.50 | #4 |
| Entry 5 | 35 | 10 | 3.50 | #5 |
| Entry 6 | 36 | 12 | 3.00 | #6 |
Entry 3 wins by 0.01 even though one voter skipped it, because 46 divided by 11 is 4.18 and 50 divided by 12 is 4.17. Entries 4 and 5 both average 3.50. The one with more ratings ranks higher. If they had the same average and the same number of ratings, they would share a rank. An entry nobody rated ranks last and shows no score.
Awards mode counts picks instead. Each guest chooses one entry per award, the entry with the most picks wins, and entries tied on the top count share the award. For chili specifically, see how to judge a chili cook-off and the chili cook-off rules.
What it does and what it does not
- It collects ballots from phones, keeps entry names hidden while voting is open, and ranks the entries when you close voting.
- It does not check who votes. Ballots are anonymous, so it cannot stop a guest from sending a second one from another browser.
- It does not weight judges against the crowd. Every ballot counts the same. To combine the two, make one scorecard for the judges and one for the guests, then merge the averages yourself. One real cook-off rule sheet splits it 80% judges and 20% people's choice ("Chili & Cornbread Cook-Off Guidelines", UNCSA, 2020 file).
- It does not pick tie-break winners for you beyond the rules above. Decide before the contest what happens when two entries share first place.
- It does not handle food safety. Hot holding and allergens are in the guides.
Questions people ask
Do guests need an app or an account?
No. They open the link or scan the QR code on the table card and tap their ratings in the browser.
When do guests see which chili is whose?
After you close voting. Until then cooks are only numbers, so nobody votes for a friend by name.
Is a 1 to 5 rating better than one vote per guest?
One vote per guest is the simplest ballot, and it works for a few entries and a big casual crowd. Ratings give a full ranking once there are six or more entries, and awards mode gives one vote per category. Pick the mode in the form above.
How many entries and how long does it last?
Up to 20 entries. The contest is deleted 30 days after you create it, or earlier if you delete it from the host page.
Is there a rules page for a work cook-off?
Yes: the office chili cook-off planner sizes pots and cups by headcount and has a lunch-hour timeline.
Good to know
- No accounts and no tracking cookies. A browser can only tell it has voted if it remembers, so a determined guest can vote twice.
- A contest holds up to 20 entries. Contests are deleted 30 days after you create them. You can delete one yourself from the host page at any time.
- Keep the host link private. Anyone who has it can close or delete the contest.
How to run a blind taste test at home
Pick a food where one bite tells you something and most guests have a favorite brand, then serve it in numbered cups and reveal the brands after voting closes.
| Theme | Entries | How to serve |
|---|---|---|
| Store brand against name brand | 4 to 6 of the same product | Salted potato chips, vanilla cookies or crackers. Pour into identical bowls. |
| Chocolate | 4 to 6 bars of similar cocoa percent | Break into squares at room temperature, on numbered paper plates. |
| Hot sauce or salsa | 4 to 5, from mild to hot | A dab on a plain cracker or tortilla chip. Taste the milder ones first. |
| Sparkling water or juice | 4 to 6 | Same temperature, same cups. Orange juice and lemonade work well. |
| Plain vanilla ice cream | 3 to 5 | Tiny scoops, served together and fast, so none melts first. |
| Cereal, popcorn or pretzels | 4 to 6 | Dry bowls, a handful at a time. |
Four to six items is a good range. Fewer gives little to compare, and tasters tend to tire after six or seven, so run a second round after a break if you have more. To keep it blind:
- Remove the packaging before guests arrive and put each item in an identical bowl, cup or plate.
- Number the items in random order, for example by drawing numbers from a hat, and keep the key on paper out of sight. Type the entries into the scorecard in that number order.
- One person prepares and does not vote, or votes last.
- Serve the same portion at the same temperature. Warm items tend to lose to cold ones.
- Put out water and plain crackers for between items, and keep scores private until voting closes.
With six guests, one person who loves spicy food can move a hot sauce a long way, so read the ranking as what this group liked on this day. Read it out from last place up, so the winner comes at the end.
Allergies: list the ingredients and ask guests about allergies before you buy. Keep the original packaging in another room, so you can check an ingredient list without unblinding anyone.
Start a blind taste test scorecard
Judging guides
- Pie contest judging sheet: the crust row, blind slices and which pies need the fridge.
- Cookie contest judging sheet: chewy, crisp and decorated cookies, and tasting plates at a swap.
- Cake contest judging: a sheet weighted toward the slice, cupcakes and cold frosting.
- How to judge a bake-off contest: bread next to cookies, a tasting order and office logistics.
- Salsa contest judging: heat classes and a mild-to-hot tasting order.
- Pumpkin carving contest judging: carved, painted and lit classes, plus entry rules.
- Halloween costume contest judging: a ballot, twelve award ideas and who should decide each, and a numbered parade.
- Ugly Christmas sweater contest judging: ugliest or best ugly, awards and a 10-minute vote.
- Office decorating contest judging: doors, cubicles, safety checks and remote staff.
- Trunk-or-treat contest judging: a sheet for decorated cars, safety checks and a visitor vote by car number.
- Christmas lights contest judging: a night route, a score sheet, and numbered QR yard signs for a neighbors' vote.
- Big game commercial ratings party: a printable ad list, paper award categories and a numbered phone vote.
- Friendsgiving dish competition: categories, anonymous numbers at a potluck, kids voting and a score sheet.
- Gingerbread house contest judging: structure, edible rules and kids' classes.
- How to judge a chili cook-off: criteria, blind cups, tie-breaks, a rule sheet for cooks and wing criteria.
- Soup cook-off judging: a soup score sheet, broth and cream classes, slow cooker rules.
- Office chili cook-off planner: pots, cups and outlets by headcount, a lunch-hour timeline and work rules.
- How to host a pie contest: rules, categories, a timeline and an entry form.