Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

Cookie contest judging sheet to print, with texture judged by cookie type

A cookie contest judging sheet gives each numbered plate points for appearance (10), texture (25), flavor (35), creativity (10) and overall (20), 100 in total. or jump to it.

Cookies are the easiest bake to put in a contest. They travel well, they are already in portions, and a cookie exchange or office bake-off often has a dozen kinds on the table. The judging sheet is right below: 100 points over appearance, texture, flavor, creativity and overall, ready to print, or run the vote on phones. After it: what each score means, and how to set up the tasting so the votes stay blind.

Start a phone scorecard See a sample

One row per numbered cookie plate. Write each score in its column and add the row into Total; the maximums in the headers add up to 100. Flavor and texture carry the most. If there is no theme, leave Creativity blank and spread its 10 points over flavor and texture. Change the weights if your swap has rules of its own.

Cookie contest judging sheet

Judge name:  

Tie: the cookie with more Flavor points takes the place. Level on Flavor as well? The judges taste those cookies again.

What each score means

Read this to your judges before the first plate. Weights differ between real sheets: the 4-H cookie sheet from Purdue Extension puts 35% on outside characteristics, 35% on inside characteristics (moist, crisp or chewy by kind, tender), 20% on appearance and aroma and 10% on the recipe card.

On the texture score, a chocolate chip cookie baked a few minutes too long, hard enough to snap when it should bend, gets 6 or 7 out of 25. One with crisp edges and a soft middle that still bends the next day gets 20 or more. Skip the creativity row if there is no theme, and spread its 10 points over flavor and texture.

What the North Carolina State Fair scores

The North Carolina State Fair premium book for open baking judges cookies and brownies on four equal criteria worth 25 points each: appearance, texture, crumb and flavor. It splits texture by how the cookie is made, which most home sheets skip.

  • Rolled, ice box or pressed: thin, crisp and tender.
  • Drop, sheet or bar: thick, soft and tender, with an even grain.
  • Crumb: tender but holds together. Tough, rubbery or crumbly loses points.
  • Appearance: uniform color and an even shape. Pale, dull, burned or off color counts against a cookie, and so does one that is too large, small, thick or thin.

The same book sorts entries into classes (chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, plain sugar, bar cookies, sandwich cookies, brownies with and without extras), so a cookie is compared with its own kind. Royal icing decorated cookies get a class of their own, marked "not tasted". At home the equivalent is one vote for taste and a second one for the decorated plates, as above.

Plates, counts and tie-breakers at a real contest

The Williamson County 4-H cookie contest (2024) scores appearance, taste, texture, creativity and an oral presentation, without publishing point values. Its entry rules are easy to borrow:

  • Each entry is at least three cookies baked in the same batch.
  • One entry per division. A baker can enter several divisions.
  • Decorations on the plate itself are not considered.
  • The oral presentation carries little weight and may decide a tie between winners.

A tie on the sheet above plays out like this. Plate 4 (a brown butter chocolate chip) and plate 7 (a gingersnap) both total 83. Plate 4 has 29 in Flavor and plate 7 has 33, so the gingersnap wins. If both had 33, the judges taste the two plates again, one cookie each, and each names a winner. Put the rule on the sheet before the first plate, the way that contest names its tiebreaker in the rules.

Pies have their own fair rules, from scratch crusts to which fillings get turned away. See the pie contest sheet, or the pie contest rules if you are also hosting one for Thanksgiving.

Filling in the sheet: two cookies

Here is one judge's row for two plates. The scores are made up to show the method; they come from no real contest. Plate 3 is a chewy chocolate chip cookie. Plate 6 is a crisp ginger cookie with a lemon glaze.

Made-up example: one judge's scores for two cookie plates
Criterion (max)Plate 3Plate 6
Appearance (10)86
Texture (25)2212
Flavor (35)2831
Creativity (10)37
Overall (20)1615
Total (100)7771

Plate 3 gets 22 of 25 on texture because the edges are crisp and the middle still bends, which is what a chewy cookie is for. Plate 6 is crisp but dry, so it gets 12 even though a ginger cookie is supposed to be crisp. Plate 6 wins on flavor and creativity (31 and 7) and still loses 71 to 77, because texture and appearance cost it 12 points against Plate 3 (10 and 2). A judge who wants flavor to decide close calls can raise its weight before the tasting. Say so before the first plate, since changing weights afterwards looks like picking a winner.

Set up tasting plates

  1. Ask every baker to bring a few extra cookies for tasting, separate from the batch for the swap or the break room.
  2. One person who is not baking puts each kind on a plain plate with a number card, in random order, and keeps the key.
  3. Cut large cookies into halves or quarters. Ten whole cookies is too much for one person, and a quarter is enough to judge texture and flavor.
  4. Put a small card next to each plate that lists common allergens, such as nuts, peanuts, dairy, eggs or gluten. Ask bakers for this when they drop off. It tells people what to skip without saying who baked it.
  5. Water or milk on the side. Coffee works too, though it hides the flavor of more delicate cookies.

Chewy, crisp and decorated: what each score means

Appearance
Even size and browning across the plate, no burnt edges or bottoms.
Texture
Judge it against what the cookie is trying to be. A chewy chocolate chip cookie should bend, a shortbread should snap and melt, a gingersnap should crunch.
Flavor
Butter, spice, chocolate or citrus coming through, sweetness in balance, a pinch of salt where it helps.
Creativity or theme
Only if the contest has a theme or invites twists, such as a new flavor pairing. Keep the weight low so a classic is not punished.
Overall
Would you take a second one? This catches cookies that score fine on each criterion but do not add up.

Plain drop cookies and elaborate decorated sugar cookies are hard to compare on one score. Either judge everything on taste alone, or run two votes: "best tasting" for all entries and "best decorated" for the decorated ones.

Cookie exchange, holiday party or office

  • Cookie exchange: do the tasting first, while everyone is still there, and announce the winner before people pack up their tins.
  • Holiday party: put the plates out with the vote link on a printed card, and close voting at a set time, for example right before gifts.
  • Office bake-off: people drift in over lunch, so leave voting open for an hour or two and post the results link in the team chat afterwards. A shared link means remote colleagues can see who won, even if they could not taste.

Prizes can stay small: a wooden spoon, a cookie jar, first pick of the swap.

Allergies and a second vote

Someone who skipped the peanut butter cookies can leave that entry unrated on the phone ballot, and it does not count against the cookie. For a separate "best decorated" vote, make a second scorecard with only the decorated entries.

Cookies are often one class among several. If the table also has pies or bread, the bake-off judging criteria show how to score different bakes on one sheet, and the pie contest sheet works the same way for a pie class. To keep bakers' names hidden, number the plates as in the blind taste test guide.

A Christmas cookie swap often has a gingerbread table next to it. Those houses are judged on structure and piping before taste, so they get their own sheet: the gingerbread house score sheet. A cake or cupcake class is covered by the cake class sheet.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Start a cookie contest scorecard. The title is filled in; add the cookies and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?