Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

Pie contest score sheet: a printable 100-point judging form

A pie contest at Thanksgiving, a Friendsgiving or a church supper has one problem a chili cook-off does not: everyone knows what Grandma's pecan pie looks like. The sheet below gives the crust its own score, since that is where most homemade pies win or lose, and the steps after it hide whose pie is whose even when the pies are famous in the family. Categories, a timeline for the afternoon and an entry form are on the pie contest rules page.

Start a phone scorecard See a sample

Pie judging sheet

One row per numbered pie. Write each score in its column and add the row into Total; the maximums in the headers add up to 100. The crust gets 20 points of its own and flavor 30. Change the criteria and weights where your contest's rules differ.

Pie contest judging sheet

Pie contest judging sheet: one row per numbered pie, points per criterion
PieAppearance (10)Crust (20)Filling (25)Flavor (30)Overall (15)Total (100)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

Judge name:  

Tie: Flavor decides, since it carries 30 of the 100 points. Two pies with the same Flavor score get a second tasting.

Tally sheet for the pie judges

Collect every judge's sheet and copy each pie's total into its row, one column per judge. Add the columns into Total and number the ranks from the highest total down. With four judges and 100 points each, the best possible total is 400. If a judge skipped a pie, leave the box empty and compare that pie on its average instead.

Pie contest tally

Pie tally: one row per entry, one column per judge, with total and rank
PieJudge 1Judge 2Judge 3Judge 4TotalRank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

What each score means

Read this to your judges before the first slice. The weights above are mine; real score sheets differ. The 4-H fruit pie sheet from Purdue Extension, for one, splits 35% outside characteristics, 35% inside characteristics, 20% appearance and aroma and 10% recipe card.

Pie contest low and high scores per criterion with maximum points
CriterionMaxLow scoresHigh scores
Appearance10Burnt or pale patches, cracked custard, collapsed top, ragged edge.Even color, a neat edge, a top that kept its shape.
Crust20Soggy or raw underneath, tough, bland, shrunk from the pan.Cooked through, flaky or tender for its style, tastes of something.
Filling25Runny, gluey, rubbery, mushy fruit, no texture.Holds a slice, tender with some shape left, well set.
Flavor30Too sweet, flat, one note, an off taste.Balanced sweetness, the main ingredient comes through, spice in proportion.
Overall15Crust and filling feel like two separate things.The slice works as one, and you would take a second one.

Two apple pies can look equally golden on top. Lift a slice: a pale, wet bottom crust that sticks to the plate gets 5 or 6 out of 20 on the crust score, and a browned base that flakes and holds its layers gets 17 or more.

How three real pie contests score

Three community pie contests (2026 and 2022) publish rule sheets, compared below. The weights differ a lot, so there is no single right sheet.

Scoring scale and criteria of three published pie contests
ContestWhat is scoredScale
Wayne County Fair fruit pie contest, 2026Appearance 20, taste 40 (flavor balance 20, crust taste 10, mouth feel 5, aftertaste 5), creativity 20 (the recipe card is worth 5 of them), overall impression 20.100 points
Custer County Fair pie and cheesecake contest, 2026Six scores of 1 to 10: appearance, crust, crust flavor, filling by variety (holds its shape, fills the crust), filling flavor, overall. Every entry starts at 5, and judges add or subtract.6 x 10
Union County Heritage Festival pie contest, 2022Overall appearance, crust, taste. At least three judges, who score without consulting each other.3 x 10

Crust counts in all three: Union and Custer County give it a score of its own, and Wayne County scores crust taste (10) on top of the filling's flavor. Taste is the biggest block at Wayne County: 40 of 100, against 30 for flavor and 20 for crust on the sheet above. To make your sheet look more like a county fair's, move 10 points from Overall to Flavor. The tie-break below works either way.

What fairs turn away

Entry rules decide what can win before anyone scores a slice. These are the ones in those three sheets:

  • Cream, meringue and custard pies. Wayne County accepts none of them. Union County takes a different route and refuses any pie that needs refrigeration, which rules out the same pies.
  • Shortcuts. At Wayne County the crust and filling must be made from scratch. A graham cracker or cookie crust is fine if the exhibitor made it, and the recipe has to come with the pie.
  • Size and pan. Wayne County wants an 8 or 9 inch pie plate, preferably disposable, because pans are sold with the pies at auction.
  • Anonymous entries. At Wayne County names stay off the pie and each entry gets a number at registration. It also allows one entry per person and keeps professional bakers out. Union County allows one pie per category, up to three.
  • Warm pies. Wayne County discourages them, since a warm pie can lose points for how it comes out of the pan.

For a Thanksgiving table, copy only the rules that fit. A family contest usually welcomes pumpkin and pecan, so settle the cream and custard question before people start baking. The pie contest rules page has a list of rules to write down, and the Friendsgiving dish guide covers a table where pie is one dish among many.

Crust, filling and the slice as a whole

Appearance
Judged on the whole pie before it is cut: even browning, a neat edge, a lattice or top crust that held its shape, no burnt spots or cracks across a custard.
Crust
Flaky or tender depending on the style, cooked through on the bottom (a pale, soggy bottom is the most common fault), and with some flavor of its own.
Filling
Set enough to hold a slice without running, yet not gluey or rubbery. Fruit should be tender and keep some shape. Sweetness should leave room for the fruit, nuts or spice.
Taste and overall
Does the slice work as a whole, crust and filling together? This is the one most people care about.

The American Pie Council's National Pie Championships use a similar split: a first impression before slicing, flavor, mouthfeel (consistency, crust and aftertaste) and overall appeal.

Slicing pies blind when everyone knows the bakers

  1. Pick one person to run the kitchen who does not vote, or who does not mind voting last.
  2. They cut every pie out of sight and plate small slivers, one plate per pie, with a number on the plate or a sticky note under it. The key (number to pie) stays on a paper in their pocket.
  3. Serve slices plain. Whipped cream and ice cream go out after voting, so a topping cannot give an entry away.
  4. A slice still shows whether it is pumpkin or apple. That is fine; blind here means voters do not know who baked it.
  5. If the appearance of the whole pie matters to you, show all the pies on one table before cutting, unlabeled and in random order, and ask people to keep their opinions to themselves.

Slivers, and which pies need the fridge

  • Cut slivers. With six pies, a two-bite piece of each is plenty, and leaves pie for dessert afterwards.
  • Pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato, chess, custard and cream pies (anything with eggs or dairy) shouldn't sit out more than two hours, so keep them in the fridge, bring them out for the tasting and put them back afterwards. The two hours come from the USDA's rule for perishable food (the danger zone), and the clock counts every minute out of the fridge, so a pie that sat on the counter before the contest has less time left for the tasting.
  • Baked fruit pies are the exception: those without eggs or dairy can stay at room temperature for up to two days, according to University of Illinois Extension.
  • Fruit pies cut cleaner after cooling for a few hours, so a pie baked that morning is easier to judge than one straight from the oven.
  • Water or black coffee between tastes helps. A very sweet pecan pie makes a tart apple taste sour right after.

Breaking a tie: a worked example

Say pie 3 (a lattice apple pie) and pie 5 (a pecan pie) both total 84. Pie 3 has 24 in Flavor and pie 5 has 27, so pie 5 wins on the tie-break. If both had 27, the judges taste the two again side by side and each names a winner; with three judges that settles it. Write the tie-break on the sheet before the first slice, so nobody sees it as a decision made after the scores were in.

With several judges, add up each pie's totals across all sheets and rank by that sum, or by the average if some judges missed a pie. For rules beyond scoring (entries per baker, categories, a timeline, an entry card), see the pie contest rules page. A mixed table with cookies or bread next to the pies is covered by bake-off judging criteria.

Cakes are judged differently from pies because they have to travel and get cut cold. The cake class sheet has a sheet weighted toward the slice, and the gingerbread house guide covers a holiday table of edible builds.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Start a pie contest scorecard. The title is filled in; add the pies and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?