Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

How to host a pie contest: rules, categories and a timeline

The pie judging guide has the 100-point sheet and how to slice the pies blind. This page covers the rest of the event: what to put in the rules, how to split the pies into categories, a timeline for the afternoon and what to ask for on the entry form.

Start a phone scorecard See a sample

Pie contest rules to write down

Put the rules in the invitation or on the entry sheet, so nobody argues at the table. These settle most disputes at a Thanksgiving, office or church pie contest.

  • Who can enter. A common rule is home bakers only. Say whether a spouse, a neighbor or a bakery counts.
  • From scratch or not. Decide on store-bought crust and canned filling before the day. Either answer works if it is written down.
  • One pie per baker in a small contest. Larger events often allow one per category.
  • Pan and size. Use a standard 9-inch pie plate, so slices are comparable. Disposable tins mean nobody has to chase a dish afterwards.
  • Whole pie, ready to cut. Pies arrive baked, cooled and uncut, with a name card that the organizer keeps out of sight.
  • Ingredient list on the entry card, so guests with allergies can check it.
  • Refrigeration. Put egg and dairy pies in the fridge on arrival. The pie judging guide lists which pies need the fridge.
  • The decision is final. One short line saves a lot of talk.

Fruit, custard and other categories

Pumpkin against pecan against apple tends to come down to which pie each person likes in general. Keep one category for up to five pies. With more, splitting helps, because one style can crowd out the rest. Four ways to split:

Ways to split a pie contest into categories
SplitGood forWatch out for
Fruit, custard or cream, nutMixed family tables with 6 to 12 piesA category with one pie in it is not a contest. Merge it.
Classic and creativeOffice contests where someone brings a pizza pieJudges need a one-line definition of "creative" in advance.
Sweet and savoryPot pie and quiche entries next to dessert piesServe savory pies first so the palate is not sugared out.
One flavor only (apple, pumpkin, key lime)Small groups that want a direct comparisonEntries look alike, so blind numbering matters even more.

Each category is its own vote with its own winner, so each one is a separate scorecard of up to 20 entries, typed in the order of your numbered plates. Keep each vote to about 10 pies or fewer, since tasters tire after that. Put both vote links on the table, labeled, so nobody rates a pecan pie in the fruit vote. The printable table card has a QR code for each one.

A sample timeline

One workable schedule for a two-hour office or family event. Shift it to fit your day.

Sample pie contest timeline
TimeWhat happens
0:00Bakers drop pies at the kitchen table. The organizer assigns numbers in random order and keeps the key.
0:20Pies are cut into slivers and plated, one plate per number. Fruit and custard pies go out as separate groups.
0:30Guests open the vote link (or scan the QR code on the table) and taste. Water and plain crackers are on the table.
1:00Voting closes. The organizer taps close and the ranking appears with the baker names.
1:10Announce the winner of each category, then reveal who baked what. Whipped cream and ice cream come out now.

Judges, crowd vote or both

  • Crowd vote. Everyone who tastes rates every pie. It suits parties and needs no recruiting. A rating takes a few seconds per pie on a phone.
  • Judging panel. Use at least three judges, and an odd number to avoid a deadlock. Give them the 100-point sheet.
  • Both. Judges pick the best pie and the crowd picks the people's choice. That gives two prizes and two winners.

Prizes and announcements

A ribbon, a trophy pie plate or first pick of the leftovers does the job. Announce the winner of each category along with the scores. Tell the other bakers where they placed too, because that is the part they remember. Put a tie-break line in the written rules as well; the chili cook-off guide explains the usual ones.

Rule questions that come up on the day

  • A baker is also a judge. Allow it only if the judge cannot tell their own pie, which blind numbering handles. Otherwise the judge leaves that pie's row empty and the panel averages the others.
  • A pie arrives late. Set a drop-off time and stick to it. A late pie can be tasted for fun and left unscored.
  • A pie is damaged on the way. Judge it as it arrives, but tell the judges so the Appearance score stays fair.
  • Two pies from the same recipe. Allow it and number them separately. A shared recipe can still produce different crusts.
  • Gluten-free or vegan pies. Give them their own category when there are at least two, or score them with the rest and label them on the card.
  • A tie for first. Pick the tie-break in advance. The pie score sheet uses the higher Flavor score and shows a worked example. A re-taste of the tied pies is the fallback.

If the same table also has cookies or bread, the mixed bake-off criteria show how to score them next to the pies, and the blind taste test guide covers keeping entries anonymous.

Entry form fields

If you collect entries ahead, ask for the baker name, the pie name, the category, the ingredients and whether it needs refrigeration. Keep the baker names off anything guests can see until voting closes. A folded index card does both jobs on the day: the organizer writes the number on the outside, the baker's name and ingredients go inside, and the card can sit next to the pie without giving anything away.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Set up a pie contest scorecard. The title is filled in; add the pies in plate order and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?