Pumpkin carving contest score sheet to print, with a lit-effect column
Start a phone scorecard See a sample
Print the numbered sheet below, one row per pumpkin, or run the vote on phones. Below it: what the points mean, number cards, painted classes and judging after dark. Entry rules and age classes are in the rules section further down.
Judging sheet
One row per numbered pumpkin. Write each score within the maximum in the column head and add the row into Total (100). Walk the row once with the lights on for carving, then again in a dim room for the lit effect.
| Pumpkin | Design (30) | Carving (25) | Lit effect (15) | Theme (15) | Impact (15) | Total (100) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | ||||||
| 3 | ||||||
| 4 | ||||||
| 5 | ||||||
| 6 | ||||||
| 7 | ||||||
| 8 |
Judge name:
Tie: the higher Design score wins. If that is level too, the judges look at the tied pumpkins once more in the dim room.
What the points mean
Design gets the most, 30, because a simple idea carved well usually beats a complicated one carved badly. The weights suit a mixed office or family contest; move points around for experienced carvers.
| Criterion | Max | Low scores | High scores | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design and creativity | 30 | A stock face or stencil with no twist, an idea that is hard to read. | A fresh idea you recognize at once, a face or scene with personality. | ||
| Carving skill | 25 | Ragged cuts, torn skin, pieces that fell out, uneven wall thickness. | Clean edges, fine detail, a mix of cut-through and shaved areas. | ||
| Lit effect | 15 | Dark or washed out, the light shows no shape. | Contrast between bright and dim areas, the design reads well in the dark. | ||
| Theme or story | 15 | Ignores the theme, or has no clear subject. | A clear nod to the theme, or a small scene that tells a story. | ||
| Overall impact | 15 | Fine, but you would walk past it. | You stop and look, and you point it out to someone else. | ||
| Total | 100 | ||||
On the carving row, jagged edges, a mouth that broke through where a tooth should be and a lid that drops inside get 6 or 7 out of 25. Clean cuts, shaved areas that glow without a hole and a lid that sits flush get 20 or more. If there is no theme, spread its 15 points over design and carving.
Number the pumpkins
- Ask entrants to keep their name off the pumpkin and anything attached to it. A small tag on the bottom is fine for the organizer.
- One person who is not entering writes a number card for each pumpkin and keeps the key. Set the cards next to the pumpkins in random order, not in the order people arrived.
- Put the pumpkins somewhere you can dim the light, with a light inside each one. Use battery lights: NFPA fire safety tips say a flashlight or battery-operated candle is the safest light for a jack-o-lantern (Connecticut fire marshal copy).
- Give judges a pen, the sheet and a minute per pumpkin.
- Close the vote before the entrants come back into the room.
Carving, shaving and the glow
- Design and creativity
- Is the idea original, and can you tell what it is at a glance? A well-known character done cleanly can still score high if the execution is good.
- Carving skill
- Look at the cut edges and the thin spots. Shaving away skin without cutting through is harder than cutting a hole, so reward it.
- Lit effect
- Judge it with the light on and the room dim. A great design that disappears in the dark loses points here.
- Theme or story
- Score it when the contest has a theme, such as movie monsters or the neighborhood. Without one, its 15 points go to design and carving as noted under the sheet.
- Overall impact
- The first reaction when the lights go down. A pumpkin can score fine on every row and still look ordinary next to its neighbors.
Carved and painted classes
A painted pumpkin has no lit effect, so it cannot compete fairly on this sheet. Use a separate painted or decorated class with its own scorecard: move the 15 lit-effect points to design and judge it under ordinary room light. Painting also suits young kids, since it keeps knives out of small hands. For carved pumpkins, a kids' class and an adult class keep a ten-year-old's first face from facing an adult's shaved portrait.
Judging lit pumpkins after dark
- Give every carved pumpkin the same kind of light, for example from one pack of LED tea lights. Otherwise the brightest light wins the lit-effect row.
- Look from the distance people will see the pumpkin on a porch, a few steps back. Fine shaving that glows up close can turn to mush at ten feet.
- Judges carry a small flashlight for the number cards and point it at the card, never at the pumpkin.
- Outdoors, put the row out of the wind and away from paths, so nobody trips over a pumpkin they cannot see.
Pumpkin carving contest rules for the carvers
Published contest rules disagree on basics like painting, so these come from four events, each with its reason: Northern Star Farm (2021), Fairytale Town (2020), the Carleton North virtual contest (2025) and the Pumpkin Masters online contest (2026).
| Rule | Reason |
|---|---|
| One pumpkin per entrant | Northern Star and Carleton North both say it. It caps the display and stops one keen carver from filling the table. |
| Real pumpkins, any size or shape | Northern Star accepts any shape or size "as long as they are real", standing without support. My reasoning: a foam pumpkin cuts differently and lasts all year, so give foam its own class if you allow it. |
| Carved only, or carved and painted as two classes | Northern Star bans paint. Carleton North takes painted or carved pumpkins, and Fairytale Town suggests painting because carved pumpkins decay fast in the Sacramento heat. Pick one and write it down. |
| Commercial stencils allowed, with a note | Northern Star allows them but gives more creativity points for handmade stencils and freehand work, and has entrants say on the card whether they used one. |
| No name on the pumpkin | Fairytale Town gives every entry an identification number and asks entrants not to cover it, so judges rate the carving without knowing who made it. |
| Content must be appropriate | Fairytale Town asks for child-friendly entries with no political or religious statements; Northern Star and Carleton North disqualify inappropriate or offensive ones. The organizer decides, before judging starts. |
| Carvers bring their own tools, kids carve with an adult | Carleton North makes tools the participant's responsibility, and Pumpkin Masters states that adult supervision is required when carving. For knives and kids, follow the rules of the venue or event you are in. |
| Pick-up deadline | Northern Star discards pumpkins not picked up by 5:00 PM on October 31, two days after judging; Fairytale Town claims any left after November 2. A deadline saves the host from a week of rotting entries. |
| Liability line | Northern Star states it is not responsible for loss or damage. One sentence is enough at a private party; a public event may want more. |
Northern Star splits entrants into kids up to 12, teens 13 to 17 and adults, with $100, $50 and $25 for first to third in each; Pumpkin Masters sorts by skill instead, with Beginner and Master Carver. For a party, two or three age brackets with one prize each plus a best of show is plenty, and a bracket with fewer than six entries merges into the next one up.
- Carve at home for an office or a neighborhood: no knives at the venue, but set a "carved no earlier than" date one to three days before judging (a rule of thumb, not a number from the events). Fairytale Town disposes of a carved pumpkin that shows signs of decay, and a cut pumpkin softens faster in a warm room.
- Carve on site for a party with a set hour: newspaper, a bin, a table per carver and a hard stop. Allow about 60 to 90 minutes for a simple face (an estimate).
- Photo entries suit remote teams. Carleton North takes one photo per entrant and lets a crowd vote, with the judges choosing the Fan Favourite from the top five. Ask for a photo taken lit.
- Lights: Carleton North allows battery-operated candles or lights during judging. Write "battery lights only; the organizer supplies them", which keeps lit candles out of a crowded room and makes every entry glow the same way.
- Table space: roughly a square foot to a foot and a half per pumpkin, so 20 entries need two 6-foot tables (an estimate; measure your largest pumpkin).
A rule sheet to copy:
- One real pumpkin per person, any size or shape, standing without support.
- Classes: [carved only / carved and painted] and [your age brackets].
- Carve it at home no earlier than [date] and bring it finished by [time].
- Stencils are fine. Say on the entry card if you used one.
- Keep your name off the pumpkin. The organizer gives you a number.
- The organizer supplies battery lights. No candles.
- Keep it friendly: no offensive, political or religious content. The organizer decides.
- Kids carve with an adult's help, and everyone follows the rules of the place.
- Prizes: judged [category], plus a people's choice by phone vote. [Which one wins a tie.]
- Collect your pumpkin by [time] on [date] or it goes in the compost.
Voting in a dim room
Keep the lights low while guests vote, so they rate the pumpkins as they look lit. Phones light themselves; put the QR card by the door or under a lamp so it can be scanned.
How the phone vote works
Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.
Start a pumpkin carving scorecard. The title is filled in; add the entries and share the link.
Create a scorecard See a sample contest