Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

Halloween costume contest judging: criteria, printable ballot and tally sheet

Start a phone scorecard See a sample

Ballot and tally sheet

Copy the ballot for each voter. Voters write the number from the costume tag next to each award and drop the slip in a box. Three awards are common on printable ballots (The Tiny Blue House's ballot set lists best, funniest and most unique costume, with a ballot box), plus two more. Rename the awards to yours.

Costume contest ballot: write one costume number per award
AwardCostume number
Scariest
Funniest
Best group
Most creative
Best overall

One pick per award. You may skip an award. Do not vote for your own costume.

Tally sheet

One row per costume number. Make a tick for every slip that names it, then count the ticks. The most ticks in an award wins it.

Costume contest tally sheet: one row per costume number, one column per award
CostumeScariestFunniestBest groupMost creativeBest overall
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Tie: the tied costumes parade once more and the room votes again on that award only.

The printable below is a ballot with one pick per award, plus a tally sheet for whoever counts. After it: a 100-point score sheet for a judging panel, the usual awards, and a numbered parade for masked guests. Judging cars instead of costumes? The trunk-or-treat sheet has its own criteria and safety checks.

Score sheet for a judging panel

For a panel that scores instead of voting: five criteria, 100 points. Creativity gets the most because money cannot buy it, and effort comes second so a homemade costume can beat an expensive one. Judges score the costume itself.

Halloween costume contest score sheet criteria with maximum points
CriterionMaxLow scoresHigh scoresScore
Creativity and originality30A store-bought costume worn as it came, an idea seen three times tonight.A fresh idea, a clever twist on a known character, a pun that lands.
Effort and craftsmanship25Put together in five minutes, loose parts, nothing made by hand.Handmade or well-assembled pieces, details that took time.
Character and commitment20Wearing it but not playing it.Voice, pose or props that stay in character all night.
Theme fit10Ignores the party theme.Clear nod to the theme. If there is no theme, spread these points over the first two rows.
Overall impact15Fine, but you would not remember it.People stop talking when it walks in.
Total100Costume or number: ______ Judge: ______

The character row is where two similar costumes split. A vampire who takes off the cape after an hour and spends the night by the snacks gets 5 or 6 out of 20. One who keeps the accent, hides from the window light and turns down the garlic bread gets 17 or more.

Categories and awards

Pick three to five of these and put them in the invitation.

Scariest
Judge the fright: makeup, a mask, sound, the way the person moves. Gore is a different thing from scary, so ask whether you would jump.
Funniest
Puns, a twist on a known character, a gag that needs no explanation. If the wearer has to explain it, it loses points.
Best group
Two or more people dressed as one idea. Judge how well the pieces fit together and treat the group as one entry. Cap the size, for example two to five people.
Most creative or best homemade
The category where the score sheet above does the most work. Give effort and originality extra weight here.
Best overall
The highest total on the sheet across everyone. Let each person enter one category plus Best overall, so one costume does not sweep the night.

Set the rules before the party: no real weapons, nothing that mocks a culture or a group of people, and a costume you can wear indoors.

Twelve costume award ideas and who decides each

Every award is one more thing to judge and count, so pick the few that fit your party.

Costume contest award ideas: what each rewards, who decides it and what to watch for
AwardRewardsWho decidesWatch for
ScariestA reaction: makeup, a mask, a slow walk.Room vote right after the paradeIt favors the biggest, loudest costumes, and gore is a different thing from scary. Ask voters whether they would jump.
FunniestA joke that lands without an explanation.Room voteAn inside joke wins its own department only. At a mixed party, use a panel from different teams.
Most originalAn idea nobody else had, well made or not.JudgesVoters lean toward costumes they already know. A twist on a known character counts; a plain store-bought one does not.
Best homemadeSewing, painting, cardboard engineering.Judges, up close after the paradeDraw the line in advance: a thrift jacket with a hand-painted back counts, a shop costume with a new hat does not. Best store-bought is the matching award at a small party.
Best pop cultureAccuracy to a movie, show, game or meme.Judges who know the sourceA room vote only works when the crowd shares the references.
Best groupPieces that only make sense together.Panel or room voteSet a size band such as three to six, so a department in matching T-shirts cannot win by headcount. A group gets one number.
Best coupleTwo costumes that complete each other.Panel or room voteWorth it at a party of pairs, not at an office. Without it, pairs compete with groups of five and lose.
Easiest group costumeThe quickest idea that still works.Room voteA joke award that gives the low-effort group a reason to turn up.
Best makeupFace and body work, including prosthetics.JudgesJudge everyone in the same light. Skip it if only two or three people paint their faces.
Best propOne made or modified item.JudgesPair it with a safety rule: real or realistic-looking weapons stay at home, and anything that moves gets a look from the host first.
People's choiceThe costume most people liked overall.Everyone, one secret ballot eachKeep it a separate prize, so one costume cannot win both a panel award and this one.
Most committedStaying in character all night.A few guests who watch for itNobody can judge it at the start, so announce it last.

How many awards for how many costumes:

Suggested costume awards by number of costumes
CostumesAwardsWho decides
Under 10Best homemade and best store-bought, or just people's choiceOne phone vote
10–25Scariest, funniest, most original, best groupRoom vote for scariest and funniest, host or panel for the rest
25–50The four above plus people's choice and one craft awardPanel of three for most, room vote for people's choice
Over 50Split groups by size, add couples and craft awardsSeveral panels, one scorecard per award
  • Let each costume win one award only; if the scariest also wins most original, the next one down gets it. Say so before the party.
  • State who decides each award in the invitation: panel, host or room vote. Judges and the host can enter for fun but not for prizes.
  • Kids' contests can split by age, for example 5 and under, 6 to 12, and teens. At a work party, add a one-line rule that costumes must suit the office and must not mock a group of people.

Parties and parades

  • Halloween party: guests mingle for hours, so a room vote fits. Costumes drift around, so judges and voters need one moment when everyone is on show.
  • School or office parade: a short walk past the audience gives everyone the same look at every entry. A small panel of staff or parents scores the categories, and the audience votes for one extra prize.
  • Kids and adults: run separate classes with a scorecard each. Split by age band such as under 12 and 12 and up, or kids and grown-ups. Entries are numbers on the ballot, so voting needs no names or ages.

Run the parade and the vote

  1. At the door, give every costume a number on a large tag or sticker. Pin it to the chest or back where it stays visible. Keep a private list of who wears which number. A group gets one number.
  2. Masks hide faces, so the number is how voters tell costumes apart. Voters never need to know who is under the mask, and the reveal can wait until the winners are announced.
  3. Hold a parade in number order: a lap around the room, or across a stage or hallway, with a short pause at the front. Everyone sees every entry once, including the ones that spent the evening in the kitchen. Groups walk together.
  4. Outdoors or in a dim room, make the number readable. Use white or reflective tags or a glow stick on the tag, and put a light where the parade stops. A dark costume with a dark tag cannot be scored.
  5. Create the scorecard and list the costumes by number. The costume example starts with award voting: Best overall, Scariest, Funniest and Most creative, one pick each (the printable ballot above adds Best group). Rename the awards to yours, or switch to rating each costume from 1 to 5. Guests open the link on their phones and can skip an award or a costume they missed. The 100-point sheet above is for a judging panel on paper.
  6. Print the "Scan to vote" sign from the page you get after creating the scorecard (the "Open the printable sign" button) and tape it by the costume line-up. Guests scan it and vote without typing an address. You can also paste the link in the party group chat right after the parade, while the costumes are fresh.
  7. Close voting when you want to announce, then read the results page. With awards, each award goes to the costume with the most picks. With ratings, the highest average wins. A panel scoring on paper can add up its sheets instead.

One scorecard holds up to 20 entries and, in award voting, up to 6 awards. Friends voting for friends skews any room vote, so some hosts keep the room vote to People's Choice and let the panel pick the rest.

In award voting, costumes with the same top number of picks share the award. With ratings, if two costumes have the same average, the one with more ratings ranks higher. If the ratings count is the same too, they share the place. For a single trophy, have the tied costumes walk once more while the judges re-score creativity alone. More tie-break ideas are on the chili cook-off page.

Halloween has other contests to run on the same night. A trunk-or-treat sheet fits a parking lot of cars, a pumpkin carving sheet fits a table of jack-o-lanterns, and a sweater contest is the next one on the calendar.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Start a costume contest scorecard. The title is filled in; add the costumes by number and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?