Skip to main content

Taste test scorecard

Ugly Christmas sweater contest judging: awards and a 10-minute vote

An ugly sweater contest asks people to reward the worst-looking thing in the room, and nobody agrees on what that means until the votes are in. A show of hands skips the question and the loudest friend wins. This page has a score sheet that spells out what earns points, the awards office and community parties tend to give, and a phone vote that fits into ten minutes of a work party.

Start a phone scorecard See a sample

Score sheet for ugliness, creativity and craft

Five criteria, 100 points, weighted for a typical office contest. Ugliness and commitment leads with 30: a sweater made ugly on purpose and worn with a straight face beats one that is only dated. Creativity follows with 25 so a good joke can beat a loud pattern. Score the sweater and what is attached to it, and keep the wearer's standing in the office off the sheet.

Ugly Christmas sweater contest score sheet criteria with maximum points
CriterionMaxLow scoresHigh scoresScore
Ugliness and commitment30Tasteful, a plain knit with one small reindeer.Clashing colors, too many themes at once, and the wearer owns it.
Creativity and humor25A store-bought novelty sweater, a joke you have seen all night.A fresh gag, a pun, a twist nobody else brought.
Craftsmanship and materials20Printed or bought as is, nothing added.Hand-sewn or glued additions, odd materials, details that took hours.
Extra features10Flat and silent.Lights, a 3D piece, a pocket with a surprise. Check that it is safe to wear.
Overall impact15Seen once at the coat rack and forgotten by dessert.People point at it from across the room.
Total100Sweater or number: ______ Judge: ______

The craftsmanship row shows the spread best. A shop-bought sweater with a printed reindeer and nothing added gets 3 or 4 out of 20. A thrift-store cardigan with felt ornaments, a tinsel hem and a plush toy stitched to the chest gets 16 or more, because every piece of that was work.

Categories and awards

One ugliest award leaves out the person who spent a weekend gluing pom-poms, so most parties split the prize. These six cover the sweaters that usually show up:

Ugliest sweater
The core award. Judge the clash: colors, patterns and add-ons that should not share a sweater.
Funniest
A pun, a gag, a sweater that gets a laugh without an explanation.
Most creative or best homemade
Handmade, restyled or built from odd materials. Give craftsmanship extra weight here.
Prettiest ugly
The sweater that is almost good-looking. A fun counterweight to the ugliest award.
Best group or couple
Matching family sweaters, or two that only make sense side by side, such as one string of lights running from one person to the next. They get one number and one score.
Best vintage
A real sweater from the eighties or nineties. Its owner gets credit for finding it.

One award per sweater keeps the same person from collecting three prizes. Lights need one rule of their own: the battery pack sits in a pocket or is taped inside the hem, with no loose wires near drinks or candles.

Contest formats for work parties

  • In the office: a room vote suits a team lunch or afternoon party, since everyone already stands around the same sweaters. Managers can sit out the vote for a prize they might win.
  • Remote or hybrid team: each person shows the sweater on camera for 20 to 30 seconds, in number order. Paste the vote link in the call chat once the last sweater has been shown. People in the office and at home use the same link.
  • Handmade and store-bought: if both are in the mix, run two classes. A sweater knit over weeks and one from a shop rack are hard to compare on a single scale.
  • Light-up and noisy sweaters: let them compete in the main class, where the Extra features row of the sheet rewards them. Ask for a quick demo of the lights or music and keep each one short. Spare batteries at the door save a sweater that goes dark before the vote.
  • Dress code: at work the sweater still has to pass it. Say in the invitation that slogans and add-ons stay office-safe, and that anything you would not wear in front of a client or a customer stays at home. Staff who face customers that day may need a sweater that comes off quickly.

A 10-minute vote at a work party

  1. Before the party, collect entries by chat or sign-up sheet and assign numbers. Keep the name list with whoever runs the contest.
  2. Minutes 0 to 4: the sweater show. Each entrant steps forward or turns on the camera for a few seconds, and the host calls out the number.
  3. Minute 4: create the scorecard with the sweaters by number and share the link in the team chat or on the call. In an office, a QR code on a screen works too.
  4. Minutes 4 to 8: everyone rates each sweater from 1 to 5. Skipping a sweater is fine, which helps people who joined late.
  5. Minute 8: close voting, read the ranking from the results page and announce the winner. The numbers keep people from voting for their desk neighbor by name.

If two sweaters finish level, re-score just those two on the ugliness row and give the prize to the higher number. The tie-break options on the chili page cover the rest.

The same party often has more than one contest. A door or desk decorating contest uses a similar sheet, and neighbors who light their houses can use the Christmas lights route and sheet. For a costume theme night, see the costume ballot.

Ugliest sweater or best ugly sweater?

These are two different prizes, and the winner changes with the wording. The ugliest sweater is the hardest one to look at: a plain acrylic knit in brown and mustard can win it without a single joke. The best ugly sweater is the most fun to look at, which usually means a clever, well-made one. The sheet above leans toward best, since creativity and craft together carry 45 points. For a pure ugliest contest, move 15 points from creativity to ugliness and print the word "ugliest" on the invitation, so voters on their phones answer the same question as the judges.

If the party also has a gingerbread table, the gingerbread house sheet scores structure and decoration separately from taste. For a neighborhood vote on lit-up houses, see how QR yard signs for a lights contest work.

How the phone vote works

Guests open one link and rate each entry from 1 to 5. Free, no account for you or your guests, deleted after 30 days.

Start an ugly sweater contest scorecard. The title is filled in; add the sweaters by number and share the link.

Create a scorecard See a sample contest

Related guides

Was this page useful?